skip to Main Content

Tax in the News – KPMG’s Tax Sham Case and the Need for Transparency in Court Proceedings

The recent news about KPMG’s tax sham case, involving the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) and Gold Line Telemanagement, has raised several eyebrows in the Canadian financial and legal sectors. As a CPA and Tax Law expert, I am particularly curious about the details KPMG is striving to keep from public knowledge. Their request to have a CRA affidavit struck from the public record raises questions about transparency and the public’s right to know.

Background of the Case

The case revolves around a $37-million tax scheme allegation, where KPMG Law initially secured a temporary sealing order, restricting public access to crucial documents. Gold Line Telemanagement, allegedly involved in a “carousel scheme,” is at the center of this controversy, accused of setting up fake business transactions to generate illegitimate tax refunds.

The Debate Over Public Access

CBC, through its media lawyer Iain MacKinnon, has been granted standing to oppose KPMG’s motion in a hearing scheduled for January 2024. MacKinnon’s stance underscores the constitutional right of Canadians to access court proceedings. This right is especially pertinent when taxpayer dollars are at stake, and allegations involve millions in potentially lost revenue due to complex tax schemes.

The Role of the Court and the Media

While courts can have legitimate reasons to seal documents, such as protecting sensitive commercial information, the principle of transparency should be the norm, not the exception. The Supreme Court’s stance since 1994 has been clear about informing the media regarding publication bans and access to court files. This principle is crucial for maintaining public trust in the judicial process and ensuring accountability.

Concerns for Family-Owned Businesses

For family-owned businesses, such cases and the secrecy surrounding them can be alarming. They illustrate the complexities and potential pitfalls of tax law, highlighting the need for transparent and ethical tax practices. The planning impact of such schemes can indirectly affect these businesses, as they often lead to increased scrutiny of what has been denied, without fully informing the public.

The Need for Clarity and Ethical Practices

As a professional in the field, I advocate for clarity and ethical practices in all financial and legal matters. Cases like KPMG’s raise important questions about the role of large accounting firms in advising businesses and their responsibility towards ethical standards but also underscore how far we should push the envelope for our clients.

This information is for discussion purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. There is no guarantee or warrant of information on this site and it should be noted that rules and laws change regularly. You should consult a professional before considering implementing or taking any action based on information on this site. Call our team for a consultation before taking any action. ©2023 Shajani CPA.

Shajani CPA is a CPA Calgary, Edmonton and Red Deer firm and provides Accountant, Bookkeeping, Tax Advice and Tax Planning services.

Nizam Shajani, Partner, LLM, CPA, CA, TEP, MBA

I enjoy formulating plans that help my clients meet their objectives. It's this sense of pride in service that facilitates client success which forms the culture of Shajani CPA.

Shajani Professional Accountants has offices in Calgary, Edmonton and Red Deer, Alberta. We’re here to support you in all of your personal and business tax and other accounting needs.