Protecting Your Legacy: How Trusts Can Secure the Future of Your Family-Owned Business in Canada

In the world of family-owned businesses, securing your legacy isn’t just about building a successful enterprise—it’s about ensuring that your hard-earned wealth is protected and passed down seamlessly to future generations. Imagine your business thriving for decades to come, with each generation smoothly stepping into leadership, free from the pitfalls of hefty taxes and legal disputes. This is where the power of trusts comes into play.

Trusts are increasingly becoming a go-to strategy for families looking to safeguard their wealth and ensure a smooth transition of their business to the next generation. Whether you’re concerned about minimizing tax liabilities, protecting your assets from creditors, or simply ensuring that your business remains in capable hands, a well-structured trust can provide the peace of mind you need.

As a tax expert with extensive experience in estate planning and wealth management, I’ve seen firsthand how trusts can transform the future of family-owned enterprises. This blog is designed to educate and guide you through the intricate aspects of trusts, helping you understand how they can be leveraged to protect your legacy. Whether you’re new to the concept or looking to refine your existing strategies, I’m here to offer insights that can make a real difference for your family’s financial future.

 

What is a Trust?

A trust, in the context of Canadian law, is a unique legal arrangement that plays a pivotal role in estate planning, asset protection, and tax management, especially for family-owned enterprises. At its core, a trust is not a separate legal entity like a corporation, but rather a relationship where one party, known as the trustee, holds and manages property for the benefit of another party, known as the beneficiary. The legal framework governing trusts allows for a flexible and structured way to manage and transfer wealth, ensuring that assets are handled according to the specific wishes of the individual who creates the trust.

Definition of a Trust

In legal terms, a trust is defined as an equitable obligation binding a person (the trustee) to manage property (the trust property) for the benefit of another person or persons (the beneficiaries). This relationship is governed by the terms outlined in a trust document, often referred to as a trust indenture or deed. Unlike corporations or partnerships, a trust does not have its own legal personality, meaning it cannot own property in its own name. Instead, the trustee holds the legal title to the trust property, while the beneficiaries hold the beneficial interest, meaning they are entitled to the benefits of the property.

For tax purposes in Canada, a trust is treated as an individual under subsection 104(2) of the Income Tax Act. This classification as an individual means that the trust must file its own tax returns and is taxed on the income generated by the trust property, except to the extent that such income is distributed to the beneficiaries.

Key Components of a Trust

To fully understand how a trust operates, it’s essential to recognize the key components that constitute a trust:

1. Settlor: The settlor is the individual who creates the trust by transferring property to the trustee. This act of transferring property is known as “settling” the trust. The settlor outlines the terms under which the trust will operate, specifying the trustees, beneficiaries, and how the trust property is to be managed and distributed. The settlor’s intention to create a trust must be clear, and the property transferred must be clearly defined.
2. Trustee: The trustee is the person or entity responsible for managing the trust property according to the terms of the trust document. The trustee holds the legal title to the property but must manage it for the benefit of the beneficiaries. Trustees have a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the beneficiaries, meaning they must manage the trust property with care, loyalty, and impartiality. Depending on the trust’s terms, there may be one or multiple trustees, and they may have discretion in how they distribute the trust’s income or capital to the beneficiaries.
3. Beneficiary: The beneficiaries are the individuals or entities for whom the trust is created. They hold the beneficial interest in the trust property, meaning they are entitled to the benefits derived from the property, such as income distributions or eventual ownership of the capital. Beneficiaries can be either income beneficiaries, entitled to the income generated by the trust property, or capital beneficiaries, entitled to the trust’s assets at the end of the trust’s term.
4. Trust Property: Trust property, also known as the trust corpus or res, is the asset or assets transferred by the settlor to the trust. This property can include cash, real estate, investments, business interests, or other valuable assets. The trust property must be clearly defined in the trust document, and it is the trustee’s responsibility to manage and preserve this property according to the trust’s terms.

Differences Between Testamentary and Inter Vivos Trusts

In Canada, trusts are primarily categorized into two types: testamentary trusts and inter vivos trusts, each serving different purposes and having distinct legal and tax implications.

• Testamentary Trust: A testamentary trust is created upon the death of the settlor, typically through a will. It comes into effect only after the settlor’s death and is commonly used in estate planning to manage the distribution of assets to heirs or to provide for minor children or dependents. For example, a parent might set up a testamentary trust in their will to ensure that their children receive their inheritance at a certain age. Testamentary trusts have historically enjoyed favorable tax treatment, such as access to graduated tax rates, although recent changes in legislation have limited these benefits to a specific type of testamentary trust known as a graduated rate estate.
• Inter Vivos Trust: Also known as a living trust, an inter vivos trust is created by the settlor during their lifetime. It becomes effective immediately upon creation and can be used for various purposes, such as managing assets, minimizing probate fees, or providing for family members. Inter vivos trusts are taxed at the top marginal rate, making them less tax-advantageous than testamentary trusts, but they offer greater flexibility and control over asset distribution during the settlor’s lifetime.

Understanding these foundational concepts is crucial for anyone considering the use of trusts in managing their family’s wealth and ensuring the seamless transition of assets to future generations. Trusts, when structured and managed correctly, can provide significant benefits, including asset protection, tax efficiency, and the fulfillment of the settlor’s wishes long after they are gone.

 

Why Use a Trust?

Trusts are a cornerstone in the strategic management of family-owned enterprises, offering a myriad of benefits that extend beyond simple asset transfer. They are particularly effective in addressing the unique challenges faced by family businesses, such as preserving wealth across generations, minimizing tax liabilities, and ensuring flexibility in how assets are managed and distributed. By understanding the specific advantages and types of trusts available, families can make informed decisions that align with their long-term goals and values.

Benefits of Using Trusts in Family-Owned Enterprises

1. Tax Advantages

One of the most compelling reasons for using a trust in a family-owned enterprise is the potential for significant tax savings. Trusts can be structured to take advantage of various tax benefits, including income splitting and deferring capital gains taxes. For instance, income generated by the trust can be allocated to beneficiaries in lower tax brackets, effectively reducing the overall tax burden on the family. Additionally, trusts can be used to defer taxes on capital gains by holding appreciating assets within the trust until they are passed on to the next generation or sold under more favorable tax conditions.

Testamentary trusts, in particular, have historically enjoyed preferential tax treatment, such as graduated tax rates, which can result in lower overall taxes on income retained in the trust. While recent legislative changes have restricted these benefits, certain types of testamentary trusts, like those designated as graduated rate estates, still qualify. Inter vivos trusts, though taxed at the top marginal rate, can still provide tax planning opportunities, especially when combined with other estate planning tools.

2. Protection of Family Wealth

Trusts are a powerful tool for protecting family wealth from various risks, including creditors, lawsuits, and even the potential financial mismanagement by beneficiaries. By placing assets in a trust, the settlor can shield them from external claims, ensuring that the family’s wealth is preserved for future generations. This is particularly important in family-owned enterprises, where the business itself may represent a significant portion of the family’s net worth.

In addition to creditor protection, trusts can safeguard assets from matrimonial claims. For example, if a beneficiary of the trust undergoes a divorce, the assets within the trust may be protected from being included in the division of matrimonial property, depending on how the trust is structured. This ensures that family assets remain within the bloodline, preserving the legacy of the family-owned enterprise.

3. Flexibility in Managing and Distributing Assets

Another key benefit of trusts is the flexibility they offer in managing and distributing assets. Unlike a straightforward will, which typically results in an outright distribution of assets upon the death of the testator, a trust allows for the ongoing management of assets according to the settlor’s wishes. This is particularly advantageous in situations where the beneficiaries may not be ready or capable of managing large sums of money or business interests.

Trusts can be tailored to provide for the specific needs of beneficiaries, distributing income and capital in a controlled manner. For instance, a trust can be set up to provide regular income distributions to a beneficiary while retaining the principal for future generations. Alternatively, a trust can be structured to delay the distribution of assets until beneficiaries reach a certain age or meet specific criteria, such as completing their education or demonstrating financial responsibility.

Common Types of Trusts Used by Family Businesses

Several types of trusts are particularly well-suited to the needs of family-owned enterprises, each offering different benefits depending on the family’s goals and circumstances.

1. Discretionary Trusts

A discretionary trust provides the trustee with full discretion over how the trust’s income and capital are distributed among the beneficiaries. This type of trust is ideal for families who want to maintain flexibility in managing their wealth and addressing the changing needs of beneficiaries. The trustee can decide to allocate more resources to beneficiaries who may need them more, such as those pursuing higher education or facing financial difficulties, while preserving the trust’s assets for the benefit of the entire family.

2. Spousal Trusts

A spousal trust is often used in estate planning to provide for a surviving spouse while preserving the capital for the next generation. In a typical spousal trust, the surviving spouse receives all the income generated by the trust during their lifetime, but the capital remains intact and is passed on to other beneficiaries, usually the couple’s children, upon the spouse’s death. This ensures that the surviving spouse is taken care of while protecting the family’s assets from being depleted.

3. Family Trusts

A family trust is a flexible and commonly used structure in family-owned enterprises, designed to manage and protect assets for the benefit of multiple family members. Family trusts are often used to hold shares in a family business, allowing income and capital gains to be distributed among family members in a tax-efficient manner. The trust can be structured to support the business’s growth while ensuring that wealth is distributed according to the family’s values and long-term objectives.

In conclusion, trusts offer a strategic way to manage, protect, and transfer wealth within family-owned enterprises. By understanding the benefits and selecting the appropriate type of trust, families can ensure that their business and legacy are preserved for future generations. Whether the goal is tax efficiency, asset protection, or flexible distribution of wealth, trusts are an essential tool in the estate planning toolkit of any family-owned business.

 

Key Considerations When Setting Up a Trust

Establishing a trust for a family-owned enterprise is a strategic decision that requires careful planning and a deep understanding of legal principles. A well-structured trust can provide significant benefits, including asset protection, tax efficiency, and controlled distribution of wealth. However, the success of a trust depends on meeting certain legal requirements and selecting the right individuals to manage and benefit from the trust. This section outlines the three certainties required for a valid trust, explains the roles and responsibilities of trustees, and discusses the importance of choosing the right trustees and beneficiaries.

The Three Certainties

For a trust to be legally valid in Canada, it must satisfy three essential certainties: certainty of intention, certainty of subject matter, and certainty of objects. These certainties ensure that the trust is clearly defined and can be effectively managed and enforced.

1. Certainty of Intention

Certainty of intention refers to the clear intention of the settlor to create a trust. The settlor must demonstrate a deliberate intention to transfer property to a trustee for the benefit of the beneficiaries. This intention is typically expressed in a trust document or deed, where the settlor explicitly states that the property is to be held in trust. Without certainty of intention, a court may not recognize the arrangement as a trust, potentially leading to unintended consequences, such as the property being treated as a gift or retained by the settlor.

2. Certainty of Subject Matter

Certainty of subject matter requires that the trust property be clearly identified. The assets that are to be held in trust must be specified, either by direct description or through a formula that allows for precise identification. Additionally, the shares of the trust property that each beneficiary is entitled to must be clearly defined. For example, if a trust is established to hold shares in a family business, the number of shares or the proportion of ownership allocated to the trust must be explicitly stated. If the subject matter of the trust is vague or uncertain, the trust may fail.

3. Certainty of Objects

Certainty of objects means that the beneficiaries of the trust must be clearly identifiable. The trust must specify who the beneficiaries are, whether by name or by a defined class, such as “the settlor’s children.” The totality of the beneficiaries must be known or ascertainable at the time the trust is created. This certainty ensures that the trustees know who they are obligated to serve and that the beneficiaries can enforce their rights under the trust. If the objects are uncertain, the trust may be void for lack of clarity.

Roles and Responsibilities of Trustees

The trustees play a central role in the administration of the trust, and their responsibilities are governed by both the trust deed and the law. Trustees hold the legal title to the trust property and must manage it for the benefit of the beneficiaries. Their duties include:

• Fiduciary Duty: Trustees have a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the beneficiaries. This means managing the trust property with care, diligence, and loyalty. They must avoid conflicts of interest and cannot profit from the trust unless expressly permitted by the trust deed.
• Prudent Management: Trustees are required to manage the trust property prudently, making investment decisions that preserve and grow the assets while considering the needs of the beneficiaries. They must act with the same care as a prudent person managing their own affairs.
• Impartiality: Trustees must treat all beneficiaries fairly and impartially, balancing the interests of income beneficiaries with those of capital beneficiaries. They cannot favor one beneficiary over another unless the trust deed explicitly allows it.
• Accountability: Trustees are accountable to the beneficiaries for their actions. They must keep accurate records of all transactions, provide regular updates to the beneficiaries, and be transparent about how the trust is being managed.

Choosing the Right Trustees and Beneficiaries

Selecting the right trustees is critical to the success of a trust. Trustees should be individuals or entities that the settlor trusts implicitly to manage the assets according to the settlor’s wishes. They should have the financial acumen and experience necessary to handle the responsibilities of the role. In some cases, a corporate trustee, such as a trust company, may be chosen for their expertise and impartiality.

However, it is also essential to consider potential conflicts of interest. For example, if a trustee is also a beneficiary, there may be a conflict between their duty to manage the trust impartially and their personal interest in maximizing their share of the trust property. To mitigate such conflicts, the trust deed can include provisions that require decisions to be made by a majority of trustees or provide for the appointment of an independent trustee.

Similarly, choosing beneficiaries requires careful thought. The settlor should consider not only who should benefit from the trust but also how and when they should receive their benefits. In some cases, it may be appropriate to appoint a trust protector or advisor to oversee the trustees and ensure that the trust is administered according to the settlor’s intentions.

In conclusion, setting up a trust involves careful consideration of legal requirements and the selection of responsible and impartial trustees. By ensuring the three certainties are met and choosing the right individuals to manage and benefit from the trust, families can create a robust framework for preserving and managing their wealth for future generations.

 

Tax Implications of Trusts in Canada

Understanding the tax implications of trusts is crucial for effectively managing and optimizing their benefits, especially in the context of family-owned enterprises. Trusts in Canada are subject to a specific set of tax rules, which govern how income is taxed, how distributions are treated, and how assets are managed over time. In this section, we will detail how trusts are taxed in Canada, explore the attribution rules that can impact income distribution within a trust, explain the 21-year deemed disposition rule, and highlight recent legislative changes that could affect the use of trusts in estate planning.

How Trusts Are Taxed in Canada

In Canada, trusts are treated as separate taxpayers under the Income Tax Act (ITA), meaning they must file their own tax returns and pay taxes on any income earned by the trust property. The taxation of a trust depends on the type of trust—whether it is an inter vivos trust (established during the settlor’s lifetime) or a testamentary trust (established upon the settlor’s death).

1. Inter Vivos Trusts

Inter vivos trusts are taxed at the highest marginal tax rate, with no access to the graduated tax rates that individuals enjoy. This means that all income retained in an inter vivos trust is taxed at the top federal rate, along with any applicable provincial rates. Because of this, inter vivos trusts are often used in conjunction with other tax planning strategies, such as income splitting or the use of capital gains exemptions, to minimize the overall tax burden.

2. Testamentary Trusts

Testamentary trusts, on the other hand, historically benefited from graduated tax rates, making them more tax-efficient compared to inter vivos trusts. However, as of January 1, 2016, changes introduced in Budget 2014 have largely eliminated these benefits for most testamentary trusts. Now, only a specific type of testamentary trust known as a graduated rate estate (GRE) and trusts with disabled beneficiaries qualifying for the Disability Tax Credit can still access graduated rates. A GRE is a trust that arises on death and exists for up to 36 months after the death of the testator, after which it is taxed at the highest marginal rate.

3. Taxation of Trust Income

Trust income is taxed either within the trust or in the hands of the beneficiaries, depending on whether the income is distributed. If the income is retained within the trust, the trust pays tax on it at the applicable rates. However, if the income is distributed to the beneficiaries, the trust can deduct this amount from its taxable income, and the beneficiaries must include the income in their personal tax returns, where it is taxed at their individual rates.

This ability to allocate income to beneficiaries, particularly those in lower tax brackets, is one of the key tax planning advantages of using a trust. However, it is essential to be aware of the attribution rules and other tax provisions that can impact how and when income can be distributed.

Attribution Rules: Sections 74.1 to 74.5 and Subsection 75(2)

The attribution rules under sections 74.1 to 74.5 and subsection 75(2) of the ITA are designed to prevent income splitting by attributing income earned by a trust back to the original transferor under certain conditions. These rules can significantly impact the tax efficiency of a trust, particularly when family members are involved.

1. Section 74.1 to 74.5

Sections 74.1 to 74.5 primarily deal with the attribution of income or capital gains to a spouse, common-law partner, or minor children when property is transferred to a trust. Under these rules:

• If a settlor transfers property to a trust where their spouse or minor children are beneficiaries, any income earned from that property is attributed back to the settlor and taxed in their hands.
• Similarly, any capital gains realized on the property may also be attributed back to the settlor.
• The attribution rules do not apply to income earned on income (i.e., second-generation income), meaning that once income has been taxed in the settlor’s hands and then reinvested, any income earned on that reinvestment is not attributed back to the settlor.

2. Subsection 75(2)

Subsection 75(2) of the ITA is a broad attribution rule that applies when the settlor retains certain control over the trust property. Specifically, it applies if the trust property (or property substituted for it):

• May revert to the settlor or a person who contributed the property to the trust;
• May pass to persons determined by the settlor or contributor after the trust’s creation; or
• Can be disposed of only with the settlor’s or contributor’s consent.

When subsection 75(2) applies, any income or capital gains from the property are attributed back to the settlor and taxed in their hands, regardless of whether the income is distributed to beneficiaries. Moreover, if subsection 75(2) applies to any trust property, the trust cannot distribute that property on a tax-deferred basis under subsection 107(2) while the settlor is alive.

To avoid the application of subsection 75(2), it is crucial that the trust be irrevocable, meaning the settlor has no possibility of reclaiming the property or determining its disposition after the trust’s creation. Additionally, the settlor should not act as a sole trustee or retain significant control over the trust property.

The 21-Year Deemed Disposition Rule

The 21-year deemed disposition rule is another critical consideration in the taxation of trusts in Canada. Under subsection 104(4) of the ITA, most trusts are deemed to dispose of their capital property at fair market value every 21 years. This rule is designed to prevent the indefinite deferral of capital gains tax within a trust by requiring the trust to recognize and pay tax on any accrued capital gains every 21 years.

The 21-year deemed disposition can have significant implications for family-owned businesses held within a trust. If a family business or other valuable assets are held in a trust, the trustees must plan for the potential tax liability that will arise at the 21-year mark. This may involve selling assets to cover the tax bill, distributing assets to beneficiaries before the deemed disposition, or using other tax planning strategies, such as triggering gains earlier when tax rates are more favorable.

To mitigate the impact of the 21-year rule, some trusts are structured to distribute assets to beneficiaries before the 21-year period ends, thus deferring the tax to the beneficiaries. Alternatively, some families use “rollover” provisions under subsections 107(2) or 107.4, which allow the transfer of certain assets from one trust to another without triggering immediate tax consequences, provided specific conditions are met.

Recent Legislative Changes and Their Impact on Trusts

Recent changes to the taxation of trusts in Canada, particularly those introduced in Budget 2014, have significantly impacted how trusts are used in estate and tax planning.

1. Graduated Rate Estates and Changes to Testamentary Trusts

As mentioned earlier, the most significant change has been the restriction of graduated tax rates to GREs and qualified disability trusts (QDTs). All other testamentary trusts are now taxed at the highest marginal rate. This change has prompted many families to reconsider the use of testamentary trusts in their estate plans, especially where income splitting and tax efficiency were primary goals.

2. Changes to Tax Planning Strategies

The elimination of graduated tax rates for most testamentary trusts has also affected common tax planning strategies, such as using multiple testamentary trusts to minimize overall tax liability. Families now need to explore alternative approaches, such as inter vivos trusts combined with other estate planning tools, to achieve their tax planning objectives.

3. Impact on Charitable Donations

The changes in legislation also include specific rules regarding charitable donations made by a GRE. GREs can allocate charitable donations to the deceased’s terminal tax return, the estate’s tax return, or a previous tax year of the estate, providing flexibility in how these donations are used for tax purposes.

In conclusion, the tax implications of trusts in Canada are complex and require careful consideration, particularly in the context of family-owned enterprises. Understanding how trusts are taxed, the impact of attribution rules, the 21-year deemed disposition rule, and recent legislative changes is essential for effective trust planning. By navigating these rules wisely, families can optimize the benefits of trusts, ensuring the preservation and growth of their wealth for future generations.

 

Case Study: Trusts in Action

Introduction to the Client’s Family Business

The family business in question is a well-established custom furniture company located in Alberta, Canada. The business has been successfully run for over 30 years, growing from a small workshop into a thriving enterprise with a strong domestic and international clientele. The company is known for its high-quality, bespoke furniture pieces, which appeal to high-end customers across Canada, the United States, and Europe.

The family dynamics within the business are typical of many family-owned enterprises. The business was founded by the patriarch, who is now in his late 60s and has been the primary decision-maker. His spouse has played a crucial role in managing the company’s finances and operations. Their two adult children are also deeply involved in the business: one oversees sales and marketing, particularly focusing on expanding into the European market, while the other manages production and operations at the Alberta headquarters.

As the founder approaches retirement, the family is faced with a significant challenge: how to ensure a smooth succession of the business to the next generation while minimizing tax liabilities and preserving family wealth. The family sought the expertise of Shajani CPA to explore the possibility of setting up a trust to manage these concerns effectively.

Problem Scenario: Managing Succession and Tax Planning

The family’s primary concerns were to secure the future of the business for the next generation, avoid potential conflicts between family members, and protect the family’s wealth from external risks such as creditor claims or matrimonial disputes. Additionally, they wanted to mitigate the potential tax burdens associated with transferring ownership of the business, particularly the capital gains tax on the business’s appreciated value and income taxes on future earnings.

To address these challenges, Shajani CPA recommended establishing a discretionary family trust to hold the shares of the business. This approach would help manage succession, protect the family’s wealth, and optimize tax planning.

Analysis of the Situation

1. Certainty of Intention and the Role of Trustees

A critical step in setting up the trust was ensuring the certainty of intention. The founders needed to clearly express their intention to create a trust, specifically stating that the business shares would be held in trust for the benefit of their children and future descendants. Shajani CPA worked closely with the family to draft a formal trust deed, outlining the terms and conditions under which the trust would operate.

Selecting the right trustees was essential to the trust’s success. The trustees would hold legal title to the business shares and manage the trust property according to the trust deed. Shajani CPA advised the family on the importance of choosing trustees with financial acumen and a deep understanding of the business. Initially, the founders decided to act as trustees, with a provision in the trust deed to appoint independent trustees or a corporate trustee in the future to ensure impartiality and professional management.

Given that the children were both beneficiaries and actively involved in the business, potential conflicts of interest were a concern. To address this, Shajani CPA recommended including provisions in the trust deed that required unanimous consent of all trustees for significant decisions or that granted the independent trustee the final say in matters where conflicts might arise.

2. Tax Benefits and Pitfalls of the Trust Structure

Establishing a discretionary family trust offered several potential tax benefits:

• Income Splitting: The trust could distribute income generated by the business to beneficiaries in lower tax brackets, effectively reducing the overall tax burden on the family. For instance, dividends from the business could be allocated to the children or future grandchildren, depending on their individual tax situations.
• Deferral of Capital Gains: By holding the business shares within the trust, the family could defer recognizing capital gains until the shares were sold or distributed out of the trust. This deferral provided significant tax savings, particularly as the business continued to appreciate in value.
• Creditor Protection: Assets held within the trust were generally protected from creditors, as the legal ownership rested with the trustees rather than the beneficiaries. This protection was crucial for preserving the business in the event of legal claims or financial difficulties faced by individual family members.

However, there were potential pitfalls to consider:

• Attribution Rules: The attribution rules under sections 74.1 to 74.5 and subsection 75(2) of the ITA could result in income or capital gains being attributed back to the founders, especially if they retained control over the trust property. To avoid these rules, Shajani CPA structured the trust as irrevocable, ensuring that the founders had no reversionary interest in the trust property or control over its distribution.
• 21-Year Deemed Disposition Rule: The trust would be subject to the 21-year deemed disposition rule, which meant that every 21 years, the trust would be deemed to have disposed of its capital property at fair market value, potentially triggering a significant tax liability. Shajani CPA advised the family to plan for this event by considering strategies such as distributing shares to beneficiaries before the 21-year mark or using other tax planning methods to mitigate the impact.
• Loss of Tax Credits: Testamentary trusts could no longer benefit from graduated tax rates, except in specific circumstances, such as being classified as a graduated rate estate (GRE) or a qualified disability trust (QDT). Shajani CPA ensured that the family understood these limitations and adjusted their estate planning strategies accordingly.

Solution: Effective Use of a Trust for Business Continuity

With Shajani CPA’s guidance, the family successfully established a discretionary family trust to hold the shares of their business. This trust structure addressed their concerns about succession, tax planning, and wealth preservation while ensuring the business remained stable and prosperous.

1. Structuring the Trust

• Trust Deed: Shajani CPA assisted in drafting a trust deed that clearly articulated the founders’ intention to create the trust. The trust was structured as irrevocable, ensuring that the founders could not reclaim the assets or exert undue control over the trust property. The deed detailed the powers and responsibilities of the trustees, the rights of the beneficiaries, and the rules governing the distribution of income and capital.
• Selection of Trustees: Initially, the founders served as trustees, given their deep understanding of the business and desire to oversee the transition. However, following Shajani CPA’s advice, they appointed an independent trustee with expertise in trust management and business operations. This independent trustee provided an objective perspective and helped manage any potential conflicts of interest.
• Beneficiaries: The primary beneficiaries of the trust were the founders’ children, with provisions for future descendants. The trust deed allowed for the distribution of income to these beneficiaries based on their needs and the trustees’ discretion. This flexible structure enabled the trustees to optimize tax outcomes while ensuring the business remained financially secure.

2. Tax Planning and Succession

• Income Distribution: The trustees had the discretion to distribute income generated by the business to the children. Given that both were actively involved in the business, this income could be structured as dividends or salaries, depending on their personal tax situations. The trust also allowed for the distribution of income to future grandchildren, once they reached a certain age or met other criteria specified in the trust deed.
• Capital Gains Deferral: By holding the business shares within the trust, the family could defer the realization of capital gains. The trust would not need to recognize capital gains until the shares were sold or distributed, allowing the family to benefit from the business’s continued appreciation without immediate tax consequences.
• Planning for the 21-Year Rule: To address the 21-year deemed disposition rule, Shajani CPA advised the trustees to periodically review the trust’s holdings and consider strategies such as distributing shares to beneficiaries before the 21-year mark. This approach ensured that the family could manage the potential tax liability without disrupting the business’s operations.
• Avoiding Attribution Rules: The trust was structured to avoid the application of attribution rules. By making the trust irrevocable and ensuring that the founders did not retain any reversionary interest or control, the trust operated independently, with income and capital gains being taxed in the hands of the beneficiaries rather than being attributed back to the founders.

The CPA’s Role

Shajani CPA played a pivotal role in guiding the family through the complexities of setting up a discretionary family trust. Our expertise in trusts and tax planning, combined with our understanding of the unique challenges faced by family businesses, ensured that the trust was structured in a way that maximized tax efficiency, protected the family’s assets, and facilitated a smooth transition of the business to the next generation.

At Shajani CPA, we specialize in helping family-owned enterprises navigate complex tax laws and develop customized estate planning solutions. Our commitment to providing personalized, high-quality service ensures that our clients receive the support they need to achieve their long-term financial and business goals. By partnering with Shajani CPA, the family secured the future of their business, protected their wealth, and positioned themselves for continued success.

Conclusion

With Shajani CPA’s expert guidance, the family successfully established a discretionary family trust that addressed their concerns about succession, tax planning, and wealth preservation. The trust structure allowed the family to optimize their tax outcomes, protect the business from external risks, and ensure that the business would continue to thrive under the next generation’s stewardship. Shajani CPA’s role in this process highlights our dedication to helping family-owned businesses achieve their goals while navigating the complexities of Canadian tax law.

 

Common Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them

Setting up a trust can be an effective way for families to manage and preserve their wealth, particularly when it comes to family-owned businesses. However, the process is fraught with potential pitfalls that can undermine the benefits of the trust if not properly addressed. This section outlines some of the most common mistakes families make when establishing trusts and offers actionable tips on how to avoid them.

1. Failure to Properly Document the Trust

One of the most critical mistakes families make when setting up a trust is failing to properly document it. A trust must be clearly defined and legally sound to be enforceable. Without proper documentation, the trust may not be recognized by the courts, which can lead to disputes among beneficiaries and potential tax complications.

How to Avoid This Pitfall:

• Engage Professional Help: Always consult with a legal professional experienced in trust law to draft the trust deed. This document should clearly outline the terms of the trust, including the roles of the settlor, trustees, and beneficiaries, as well as the distribution of assets and any specific instructions for managing the trust property.
• Detail the Three Certainties: Ensure that the trust deed clearly demonstrates the three certainties required for a valid trust: certainty of intention, certainty of subject matter, and certainty of objects. This means the settlor’s intention to create the trust must be explicit, the trust property must be clearly identified, and the beneficiaries must be clearly defined.
• Regularly Review and Update: As family circumstances and tax laws change, it’s important to periodically review and update the trust documentation. This ensures that the trust remains relevant and effective in meeting the family’s goals.

2. Choosing Trustees Without Considering Potential Conflicts

Another common mistake is choosing trustees without fully considering potential conflicts of interest. Trustees are responsible for managing the trust’s assets and making decisions that affect the beneficiaries. If a trustee has a conflict of interest—such as being both a trustee and a beneficiary—they may be unable to act impartially, leading to disputes or even legal challenges.

How to Avoid This Pitfall:

• Carefully Select Trustees: When choosing trustees, consider their ability to act impartially and in the best interests of all beneficiaries. Ideally, trustees should be individuals who are trusted by the family but are not beneficiaries themselves. If family members are chosen as trustees, it’s important to ensure they understand their fiduciary duties and are committed to acting fairly.
• Consider Appointing an Independent Trustee: To minimize the risk of conflicts, consider appointing an independent trustee, such as a professional trust company or a trusted advisor who is not a family member. An independent trustee can provide objective oversight and help ensure that the trust is managed according to its terms.
• Define Trustee Powers and Responsibilities: Clearly outline the powers and responsibilities of the trustees in the trust deed. This can include provisions for decision-making processes, such as requiring unanimous consent for certain decisions or granting a final say to an independent trustee in cases of conflict.

3. Misunderstanding Tax Implications

Misunderstanding the tax implications of setting up a trust is a common and costly mistake. Trusts in Canada are subject to specific tax rules, including the attribution rules and the 21-year deemed disposition rule. Failing to understand these rules can lead to unexpected tax liabilities and undermine the financial benefits of the trust.

How to Avoid This Pitfall:

• Consult with a Tax Professional: Before setting up a trust, consult with a tax professional who understands the complex tax rules governing trusts in Canada. They can help you structure the trust in a way that minimizes tax liabilities and avoids common pitfalls, such as triggering attribution rules or facing a large tax bill due to the 21-year deemed disposition rule.
• Plan for the 21-Year Rule: Be aware of the 21-year deemed disposition rule, which requires most trusts to recognize and pay tax on any accrued capital gains every 21 years. Plan for this event by considering strategies such as distributing assets to beneficiaries before the 21-year mark or using tax-deferred rollover provisions.
• Understand Attribution Rules: Ensure that the trust is structured to avoid triggering attribution rules, which could result in income or capital gains being taxed in the hands of the settlor rather than the beneficiaries. This often involves making the trust irrevocable and ensuring that the settlor does not retain control over the trust property.

Conclusion

Setting up a trust is a powerful tool for managing and preserving family wealth, but it requires careful planning and execution to avoid common pitfalls. By ensuring that the trust is properly documented, selecting trustees with care, and fully understanding the tax implications, families can maximize the benefits of their trust and ensure its long-term success. Partnering with professionals, such as those at Shajani CPA, can provide the guidance needed to navigate these complexities and establish a trust that effectively meets your family’s financial goals.

 

Conclusion

In this blog, we have explored the critical role that trusts play in managing and preserving family wealth, particularly for family-owned enterprises. We began by defining what a trust is under Canadian law, highlighting its key components, and differentiating between testamentary and inter vivos trusts. We then delved into the numerous benefits of using trusts in family businesses, such as tax advantages, protection of family wealth, and the flexibility in managing and distributing assets.

We also outlined the key considerations when setting up a trust, emphasizing the importance of meeting the three certainties, selecting the right trustees, and understanding the legal and fiduciary responsibilities involved. The tax implications of trusts were discussed in detail, covering the taxation of trust income, the impact of attribution rules, and the 21-year deemed disposition rule. We reinforced these concepts with a real-world case study, illustrating how Shajani CPA successfully assisted a family business in establishing a trust to manage succession, minimize tax liabilities, and protect their wealth.

Finally, we highlighted common pitfalls that families often encounter when setting up trusts and provided actionable tips on how to avoid these mistakes. Proper documentation, careful selection of trustees, and a clear understanding of tax implications are essential to the successful establishment and operation of a trust.

Trusts are a powerful tool for ensuring the smooth transition of family-owned enterprises and safeguarding family wealth across generations. However, the complexities involved in setting up and managing a trust require careful planning and professional guidance. It is crucial to consult with a tax expert or legal advisor who can tailor a trust strategy to your specific needs, ensuring that your family’s financial goals are met and that the trust operates effectively within the framework of Canadian law.

Call to Action

If you are considering setting up a trust for your family-owned business, or if you want to learn more about how trusts can benefit your wealth management strategy, we invite you to contact Shajani CPA for a consultation. Our team of experienced professionals is here to help you navigate the complexities of trust law and tax planning, providing you with a customized solution that aligns with your family’s goals.

To further assist you, we offer additional resources, including a downloadable guide on setting up trusts for Canadian families. This guide provides valuable insights into the different types of trusts, the legal and tax considerations involved, and practical tips for ensuring your trust is structured for success.

Contact us today to schedule your consultation and take the first step toward securing your family’s financial future with a well-structured trust.

 

This information is for discussion purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. There is no guarantee or warrant of information on this site and it should be noted that rules and laws change regularly. You should consult a professional before considering implementing or taking any action based on information on this site. Call our team for a consultation before taking any action. ©2024 Shajani CPA.

Shajani CPA is a CPA Calgary, Edmonton and Red Deer firm and provides Accountant, Bookkeeping, Tax Advice and Tax Planning service.

Trusts – Estate Planning – Tax Advisory – Tax Law – T2200 – T5108 – Audit Shield – Corporate Tax – Personal Tax – CRA – CPA Alberta – Russell Bedford – Income Tax – Family Owned Business – Alberta Business – Expenses – Audits – Reviews – Compilations – Mergers – Acquisitions – Cash Flow Management – QuickBooks – Ai Accounting – Automation – Startups – Litigation Support – International Tax – US Tax – Business Succession Planning – Business Purchase – Sale of Business