Disclosing the Basis of Accounting in Compiled Financial Information

Disclosing the basis of accounting in compiled financial information involves clearly explaining the set of rules or principles used to prepare financial statements. For family-owned enterprises, maintaining transparent and accurate financial records is crucial for your business’s success and sustainability. One critical aspect of this transparency is the proper disclosure of the basis of accounting used in preparing your compiled financial information. In this blog, we will delve into the requirements of CSRS 4200 and explore why correctly disclosing the basis of accounting is essential for family-owned businesses.

Understanding the requirements of CSRS 4200 ensures that your compiled financial information is clear, accurate, and reliable. This standard is particularly important for businesses with multiple stakeholders, such as family-owned enterprises, as it helps users understand how the financial information was prepared, aiding in decision-making and fostering trust. Read on to discover the importance of proper disclosure, common bases of accounting, and practical guidance to help your business adhere to these standards.

Understanding CSRS 4200

Overview of CSRS 4200: What is it and Why it Matters

CSRS 4200, or the Canadian Standard on Related Services 4200, is a set of guidelines established by the Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (AASB) for practitioners engaged in compiling financial information. This standard came into effect to address the need for clear and consistent practices in the preparation of compiled financial statements.

The essence of CSRS 4200 lies in its structured approach to compilation engagements. It ensures that practitioners follow a uniform set of procedures, enhancing the reliability and credibility of the financial information presented. For family-owned enterprises, adherence to CSRS 4200 is particularly crucial as it fosters trust among stakeholders, including family members, investors, creditors, and regulatory bodies.

In essence, CSRS 4200 matters because it:

• Establishes a Framework: It provides a standardized approach to compiling financial information, ensuring consistency across engagements.
• Enhances Reliability: By adhering to these standards, the compiled financial information is deemed more reliable and credible.
• Promotes Transparency: Clear disclosure of the basis of accounting and other relevant notes ensures that all users of the financial statements have a transparent view of the company’s financial position.

Purpose of the Standard: Ensuring Clarity and Transparency in Financial Reporting

The primary purpose of CSRS 4200 is to ensure clarity and transparency in financial reporting. This is achieved through several key objectives:

1. Uniformity in Practices: CSRS 4200 mandates a uniform approach to compilation engagements, which helps in maintaining consistency and comparability of financial information across different entities and periods.
2. Clear Disclosure Requirements: One of the critical aspects of CSRS 4200 is the requirement to include a note in the compiled financial information that describes the basis of accounting applied. This note is vital as it provides users with a clear understanding of the accounting principles and practices used in preparing the financial statements.
3. User Understanding: The standard aims to ensure that the users of the financial information, whether they are family members, managers, creditors, or investors, have a clear and accurate understanding of how the financial information was compiled. This helps in making informed decisions based on the financial statements.
4. Enhanced Communication: By requiring detailed note disclosures and promoting transparency, CSRS 4200 facilitates better communication between the preparers of financial information and its users. This reduces the risk of misinterpretation and enhances the overall credibility of the financial statements.

For family-owned enterprises, the clarity and transparency promoted by CSRS 4200 are essential. These businesses often involve multiple stakeholders who rely on accurate and transparent financial information for decision-making. By adhering to CSRS 4200, family-owned enterprises can ensure that their financial reporting meets high standards of quality and reliability, thereby fostering trust and confidence among all stakeholders.

In summary, CSRS 4200 plays a pivotal role in ensuring that compiled financial information is prepared consistently, transparently, and reliably, which is especially important for family-owned businesses aiming to maintain trust and credibility in their financial reporting.

Importance of Disclosing the Basis of Accounting

What is the Basis of Accounting?: Definition and Examples

The basis of accounting refers to the specific accounting principles and methods used to prepare financial statements. It determines how transactions and financial events are recognized, measured, presented, and disclosed in the financial reports. The basis of accounting can significantly impact the portrayal of a company’s financial health and performance.

Here are some common examples of bases of accounting:

• Cash Basis of Accounting: Under this method, revenues and expenses are recognized only when cash is received or paid. It is straightforward and easy to implement but may not always provide a complete picture of financial performance, especially for long-term financial planning.
• Cash Basis of Accounting with Selected Accruals and Accounting Estimates: This hybrid approach combines the cash basis with selected accruals and estimates. It allows for recognizing some non-cash items, such as depreciation or accrued expenses, providing a more nuanced view than pure cash basis accounting.
• Basis of Accounting Prescribed by a Contract or Agreement: Sometimes, the basis of accounting is determined by the terms of a specific contract or regulatory requirement. This can include accounting rules stipulated by a creditor or regulatory body, tailored to meet particular reporting needs or compliance requirements.

Understanding and clearly defining the basis of accounting used is crucial for the accuracy and reliability of the financial statements.

Why Disclosure Matters: Helping Users Understand Financial Statements

Disclosing the basis of accounting is essential because it provides users of the financial statements with crucial context about how the financial information was prepared. This disclosure ensures transparency and enhances the credibility and reliability of the financial statements. Here’s why it matters:

• Enhances Transparency: By disclosing the basis of accounting, businesses provide a clear and understandable explanation of the accounting methods and principles applied. This transparency helps users to understand the financial statements better, fostering trust and confidence in the reported information.
• Improves Comparability: When the basis of accounting is disclosed, it allows users to compare financial statements across different periods and with other businesses. This comparability is vital for making informed investment, lending, and management decisions.
• Aids Decision-Making: Stakeholders, including family members, investors, creditors, and regulatory bodies, rely on financial statements to make critical decisions. Knowing the basis of accounting helps them assess the financial health, performance, and sustainability of the business more accurately.
• Ensures Compliance: Proper disclosure of the basis of accounting ensures compliance with regulatory standards like CSRS 4200. This compliance not only avoids legal and regulatory issues but also upholds the integrity of the financial reporting process.
• Prevents Misinterpretation: Without clear disclosure, users might misinterpret the financial information, leading to incorrect conclusions and potentially adverse decisions. For instance, financial statements prepared on a cash basis might appear significantly different from those prepared on an accrual basis. Clear disclosure helps users understand these differences and interpret the information correctly.

For family-owned enterprises, where financial transparency and accuracy are paramount, disclosing the basis of accounting is a critical practice. It ensures that all stakeholders have a clear and accurate understanding of the financial statements, supporting better decision-making and fostering a culture of trust and reliability in the financial reporting process.

By adhering to CSRS 4200 and ensuring proper disclosure, family-owned businesses can enhance the clarity, transparency, and usefulness of their financial information, ultimately contributing to their long-term success and sustainability.

Common Bases of Accounting in Compilation Engagements

Cash Basis of Accounting: Explanation and Usage

The cash basis of accounting is a straightforward method where revenues and expenses are recognized only when cash is actually received or paid. This approach is simple and easy to implement, making it a popular choice for small businesses and family-owned enterprises.

Explanation:

• Revenue Recognition: Revenue is recorded when cash is received from customers.
• Expense Recognition: Expenses are recorded when cash is paid out to suppliers or for other business expenses.

Usage:

• Simplicity: The cash basis of accounting is simpler to maintain compared to other methods, as it does not require tracking receivables or payables.
• Short-Term Focus: It provides a clear picture of cash flow, which can be useful for short-term financial planning and day-to-day management of the business.
• Limitations: This method may not provide a complete view of the business’s financial performance and position, especially for long-term planning and analysis, as it ignores receivables, payables, and non-cash transactions.

Cash Basis with Selected Accruals and Accounting Estimates: What it Entails

The cash basis of accounting with selected accruals and accounting estimates is a hybrid approach that combines elements of both the cash basis and the accrual basis of accounting. This method aims to provide a more comprehensive view of a business’s financial performance by incorporating certain non-cash items.

What it Entails:

• Selected Accruals: Incorporates specific accruals, such as accounts receivable and accounts payable, into the financial statements. This means recognizing revenue when earned and expenses when incurred, even if cash has not yet been exchanged.
• Accounting Estimates: Includes certain estimates, such as depreciation, amortization, and provisions for bad debts. These estimates provide a more accurate reflection of the business’s financial position and performance over time.

Usage:

• Balanced View: This approach offers a balanced view by combining the simplicity of the cash basis with the accuracy of accrual accounting. It provides more useful information for stakeholders who need to understand the true financial performance of the business.
• Customization: Allows businesses to tailor their financial reporting to better reflect their unique operations and financial situation, enhancing the relevance and usefulness of the financial statements.

Contractual or Regulatory Basis: Examples and Applications

In some cases, the basis of accounting is determined by the terms of a specific contract or regulatory requirement. This basis of accounting is tailored to meet the specific needs of creditors, regulators, or other stakeholders who require customized financial information.

Examples:

• Contractual Basis: A business might prepare financial statements according to the requirements of a loan agreement. For instance, a lender might require the business to recognize certain revenues and expenses in a specific manner to comply with the terms of the loan covenant.
• Regulatory Basis: Regulatory bodies may prescribe specific accounting practices for compliance purposes. For example, a government agency might require certain financial disclosures for businesses operating in regulated industries, such as utilities or financial services.

Applications:

• Specific Needs: This basis of accounting is used to meet the specific needs of external parties, ensuring that the financial statements provide the necessary information for compliance or contractual purposes.
• Tailored Reporting: It ensures that financial reporting aligns with the unique requirements of the agreement or regulation, which might differ significantly from general-purpose financial reporting frameworks like ASPE or IFRS.

For family-owned enterprises, selecting the appropriate basis of accounting and properly disclosing it in the financial statements is crucial. Each method has its advantages and limitations, and the choice will depend on the specific needs of the business and its stakeholders. By understanding and correctly applying these bases of accounting, family-owned businesses can ensure their financial statements are both accurate and useful, supporting better decision-making and fostering trust among stakeholders.

 

Proper Note Disclosure as per CSRS 4200

Requirements for Note Disclosure: What Needs to be Included

CSRS 4200 mandates that a note be included in the compiled financial information, describing the basis of accounting applied in preparing the financial statements. This requirement is crucial for ensuring transparency and clarity, helping users understand how the financial information was compiled.

Key Requirements for Note Disclosure:

• Basis of Accounting: Clearly describe the basis of accounting used (e.g., cash basis, cash basis with selected accruals, contractual or regulatory basis).
• Accounting Policies: Summarize the significant accounting policies applied in preparing the financial statements.
• Scope and Limitations: Outline any limitations or departures from a recognized financial reporting framework (e.g., deviations from ASPE).
• Clarity and Precision: Avoid vague or imprecise language. Ensure the note is clear, concise, and accurately reflects the accounting methods used.
• User Understanding: The note should be written in a way that is easily understood by users of the financial statements, providing sufficient detail to allow for informed decision-making.

Examples from Appendix C: How to Structure and Phrase Your Notes

Appendix C of the Practitioner’s Implementation Tool offers several examples of how to effectively structure and phrase notes on the basis of accounting in the compiled financial information. These examples can serve as a template for creating clear and comprehensive disclosures.

Example 1: Cash Basis of Accounting

The financial statements have been prepared on the cash basis of accounting. Under this basis, revenues are recognized when cash is received, and expenses are recognized when cash is paid. This method does not take into account receivables, payables, or other non-cash items.

Example 2: Cash Basis with Selected Accruals and Accounting Estimates

The financial statements have been prepared using a combination of the cash basis and selected accruals and accounting estimates. Revenues are recognized when cash is received, while certain expenses, such as depreciation and provisions for bad debts, are recognized on an accrual basis. This approach provides a more comprehensive view of the company’s financial position than a pure cash basis.

Example 3: Contractual or Regulatory Basis

The financial statements have been prepared in accordance with the accounting requirements prescribed by the loan agreement with XYZ Bank. Under this basis, certain revenues and expenses are recognized in accordance with the terms outlined in the agreement, which may differ from generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) or ASPE.

Structuring the Notes:

1. Title: Clearly label the note with a heading such as “Basis of Accounting”.
2. Opening Statement: Begin with a straightforward declaration of the basis of accounting used.
3. Detailed Description: Provide a detailed explanation of the accounting methods and policies applied. Include any significant accounting policies that impact the financial statements.
4. Scope and Limitations: Clearly outline any limitations or deviations from standard accounting frameworks.
5. Clarity and User-Focus: Ensure the language is clear and free of jargon. The note should be easily understandable by users who may not have extensive accounting knowledge.

By adhering to these guidelines and using the examples from Appendix C as a template, family-owned enterprises can ensure their note disclosures are both compliant with CSRS 4200 and useful to users of the financial statements. Proper note disclosure not only fulfills regulatory requirements but also enhances the transparency and reliability of the financial reporting, fostering trust and confidence among stakeholders.

 

Common Pitfalls and Inspection Findings

Misleading Notes: Issues with Referring to ASPE

One of the common pitfalls in note disclosure is the misleading reference to Accounting Standards for Private Enterprises (ASPE). This occurs when the notes suggest compliance with ASPE, but the compiled financial information does not meet all the recognition, measurement, presentation, and disclosure requirements of ASPE.

Issues:

• Partial Compliance: Notes that imply partial compliance with ASPE can be misleading. Users might assume that the financial statements fully adhere to ASPE standards, which can result in incorrect interpretations and decisions.
• Clarity: Misleading references can obscure the true basis of accounting used, reducing the transparency and reliability of the financial statements.

Example of Misleading Note:

“The financial statements have been prepared in accordance with ASPE, except for the exclusion of a cash flow statement and certain disclosures.” This note is misleading because it implies full compliance with ASPE, which is not accurate.

Compliance Misstatements: Avoiding Incorrect Claims of Compliance with ASPE

Compliance misstatements occur when the notes incorrectly claim that the financial statements comply with ASPE. This is a significant issue because it can mislead users into believing that the financial information meets the rigorous standards set by ASPE.

Avoiding Compliance Misstatements:

• Accurate Representation: Ensure that the notes accurately reflect the basis of accounting used. If the financial statements do not fully comply with ASPE, do not claim or imply that they do.
• Detailed Disclosure: Provide detailed explanations of how the financial statements were prepared and highlight any deviations from ASPE.

Example of Compliance Misstatement:

“The financial statements comply with ASPE, except for minor deviations.” This statement is problematic because it suggests full compliance with ASPE, which can be misleading if the financial statements do not meet all ASPE requirements.

Qualifying Language: The Problem with Imprecise Terms

Using imprecise or qualifying language in note disclosures can create confusion and reduce the clarity and usefulness of the financial statements. Terms like “substantially complies” or “mostly follows” are vague and do not provide a clear picture of the accounting basis used.

Problems with Imprecise Terms:

• Lack of Clarity: Qualifying language can obscure the true nature of the financial statements, making it difficult for users to understand the basis of accounting applied.
• Misinterpretation: Users might misinterpret the financial information, leading to incorrect decisions based on incomplete or unclear disclosures.

Example of Imprecise Qualifying Language:

“The financial statements substantially comply with ASPE.” This statement is vague and does not clearly communicate the extent to which the financial statements follow ASPE.

Best Practices to Avoid Pitfalls:

• Clear and Accurate Descriptions: Always use clear, precise language to describe the basis of accounting. Avoid vague terms and ensure that the note accurately reflects the accounting practices used.
• Avoid Implications of Full Compliance: Unless the financial statements meet all ASPE requirements, do not imply or state that they comply with ASPE.
• Detailed Explanations: Provide comprehensive explanations of any deviations from recognized accounting standards and the reasons for these deviations.

By avoiding these common pitfalls and adhering to best practices in note disclosure, family-owned enterprises can enhance the transparency and reliability of their financial statements. Proper note disclosure not only fulfills regulatory requirements but also ensures that all stakeholders have a clear and accurate understanding of the financial information, fostering trust and informed decision-making.

 

Practical Guidance for Family-Owned Enterprises

Steps to Ensure Proper Disclosure: Checklist for Businesses

Ensuring proper disclosure in financial statements is crucial for transparency and accuracy. Here is a checklist to help family-owned enterprises adhere to CSRS 4200 requirements and avoid common pitfalls:

Checklist for Proper Disclosure:

1. Identify the Basis of Accounting:

Determine the basis of accounting used (e.g., cash basis, cash basis with selected accruals, contractual or regulatory basis).

2. Accurately Describe the Basis of Accounting:

Clearly and precisely describe the basis of accounting in the notes.

Avoid using vague or imprecise language.

3. Summarize Significant Accounting Policies:

Provide a summary of the significant accounting policies applied in preparing the financial statements.

4. Highlight Deviations from Recognized Standards:

Outline any limitations or departures from recognized financial reporting frameworks (e.g., ASPE).

Ensure that the note does not imply full compliance with ASPE unless all requirements are met.

5. Use Clear and Understandable Language:

Write the note in plain language that can be easily understood by users of the financial statements.

Avoid technical jargon and complex terminology.

6. Review for Consistency and Accuracy:

Ensure that the note is consistent with the rest of the financial statements.

Double-check for accuracy and completeness.

7. Reference Examples from Appendix C:

Use examples from Appendix C of the Practitioner’s Implementation Tool as a guide for structuring and phrasing the notes.

8. Consult with a Professional Accountant:

Seek advice from a professional accountant if unsure about how to properly disclose the basis of accounting.

When to Consider Audit or Review Engagements: Situations Warranting More Thorough Engagements

While compilation engagements are often sufficient for many family-owned enterprises, there are situations where an audit or review engagement may be more appropriate. These engagements provide a higher level of assurance and can be crucial in certain circumstances.

Situations Warranting More Thorough Engagements:

1. Stakeholder Requirements:

If lenders, investors, or other stakeholders require higher assurance on the financial statements, an audit or review engagement might be necessary.

2. Complex Financial Transactions:

When the business engages in complex financial transactions or deals with significant estimates and judgments, an audit or review can provide more detailed verification.

3. Regulatory Compliance:

Certain industries or regulatory bodies may require an audit or review to ensure compliance with specific standards and regulations.

4. Business Growth and Expansion:

As the business grows and expands, the need for more comprehensive financial reporting increases. An audit or review can provide a more thorough analysis of the financial health and performance of the business.

5. Internal Controls and Risk Management:

An audit or review can help assess the effectiveness of internal controls and identify areas of risk, providing valuable insights for improving financial management.

6. Planning for the Future:

When preparing for significant future events, such as mergers, acquisitions, or succession planning, a higher level of assurance can be beneficial.

Deciding on the Appropriate Engagement:

• Compilation Engagement: Suitable for businesses that need basic financial statements without the need for extensive verification or assurance.
• Review Engagement: Provides limited assurance, suitable for businesses needing some level of verification but not as extensive as an audit.
• Audit Engagement: Provides the highest level of assurance, suitable for businesses requiring thorough verification of their financial statements.

Consulting with Professionals:

• Discuss with your accountant or financial advisor to determine the most appropriate type of engagement for your business needs.
• Consider the costs and benefits of each type of engagement to make an informed decision.

By following these practical guidelines, family-owned enterprises can ensure proper disclosure in their financial statements and determine when a more thorough engagement is necessary. This approach not only enhances the transparency and reliability of financial reporting but also supports informed decision-making and fosters trust among stakeholders.

Conclusion

Recap of Key Points

Proper disclosure in financial statements is essential for transparency, accuracy, and reliability. Understanding and adhering to CSRS 4200 ensures that family-owned enterprises provide clear and comprehensive information, helping users make informed decisions. Key points to remember include:

• The importance of accurately describing the basis of accounting.
• The necessity of avoiding misleading notes and compliance misstatements.
• The significance of using clear, precise language in note disclosures.
• Recognizing when to consider audit or review engagements for higher assurance.

For family-owned enterprises, ensuring proper financial reporting is crucial. We encourage you to seek professional guidance to navigate the complexities of financial disclosure and compliance. Consulting with a trusted accounting professional can help you avoid common pitfalls and enhance the credibility of your financial statements.

Final Thoughts

Transparency and compliance in financial reporting are not just regulatory requirements but also key drivers of trust and confidence among stakeholders. By committing to proper disclosure and accurate financial reporting, you can support the sustainable growth and success of your family-owned business.

At Shajani CPA, we specialize in providing expert accounting services tailored to the unique needs of family-owned enterprises. Our team is dedicated to helping you achieve your ambitions with clarity and confidence. Contact us today to ensure your financial statements meet the highest standards of transparency and accuracy. Tell us your ambitions, and we will guide you there.

 

This information is for discussion purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. There is no guarantee or warrant of information on this site and it should be noted that rules and laws change regularly. You should consult a professional before considering implementing or taking any action based on information on this site. Call our team for a consultation before taking any action. ©2024 Shajani CPA.

Shajani CPA is a CPA Calgary, Edmonton and Red Deer firm and provides Accountant, Bookkeeping, Tax Advice and Tax Planning service.

Trusts – Estate Planning – Tax Advisory – Tax Law – T2200 – T5108 – Audit Shield – Corporate Tax – Personal Tax – CRA – CPA Alberta – Russell Bedford – Income Tax – Family Owned Business – Alberta Business – Expenses – Audits – Reviews – Compilations – Mergers – Acquisitions – Cash Flow Management – QuickBooks – Ai Accounting – Automation – Startups – Litigation Support – International Tax – US Tax – Business Succession Planning – Business Purchase – Sale of Business