Capital Gains Crackdown: How Trudeau’s Misguided Tax Reforms Could Stifle Canadian Small Businesses and Stall Economic Growth

The Canadian Federal Government’s Budget 2024 has introduced sweeping revisions to the capital gains tax regime, signaling a profound shift in the fiscal environment for investors and family-owned businesses throughout the nation. These modifications, set to recalibrate the tax landscape, necessitate a thorough analysis not just of their direct consequences but also of their wider impact on Canada’s economic vitality and competitive standing in the global market. As we explore these pivotal changes, it is essential to grasp how they might influence both short-term financial decisions and long-term investment strategies, further diminishing Canada’s appeal as a destination for both domestic and international capital. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s remarks in September 2015 that “a large percentage of small businesses are actually just ways for wealthier Canadians to save on their taxes” reveal a misunderstanding of the critical role these enterprises play in job creation and economic stability. This perspective appears to continue influencing current tax policies, such as the indiscriminate increase in the capital gains inclusion rate for all corporations, which could hinder economic growth under his leadership. Without a nuanced approach that recognizes the positive contributions of small businesses, Canada’s economic prosperity may remain elusive.

Overview of the Capital Gains Tax Changes
Starting June 25, 2024, all capital gains realized by corporations will have their inclusion rate increased from one-half to two-thirds. This means that 67% of capital gains will be included in taxable income, up from the current 50%. For individuals, the inclusion rate for capital gains exceeding $250,000 annually will be 67%. For gains up to $250,000 for individuals, the inclusion rate remains at 50%.

• All capital gains realized by corporations will see their inclusion rate increase from 50% to 67%, meaning that two-thirds of capital gains will be included in taxable income.
• For individuals, capital gains exceeding $250,000 annually will also be taxed at the increased inclusion rate of 67%.
• The inclusion rate for individual capital gains up to $250,000 per year will remain unchanged at 50%.

This adjustment aims to increase tax fairness by aligning the tax rates more closely with those on wage income, particularly affecting what the government deems to be high-income earners that disproportionately benefit under the current regime.

Additionally, the lifetime capital gains exemption on the sale of small business shares, and certain other properties, will rise from approximately $1 million to $1.25 million, supporting small business owners and entrepreneurs.

The Impact on Investment
One of the pivotal concerns arising from the proposed increase in the capital gains tax, as outlined in Canada’s Budget 2024, is its potential to significantly impact investment trends within the country. Higher taxes on capital gains could lead to a noticeable decrease in the attractiveness of long-term investments in sectors that are crucial for driving innovation and expanding the economy. Particularly affected could be growing industries and startups that rely heavily on robust investment inflows to scale operations and break new ground.
When capital gains taxes rise, the effective return on investment diminishes. This change might make investors think twice before committing capital to ventures that, while potentially lucrative, carry higher risks. Such hesitancy could be especially pronounced in innovative sectors like technology, biotech, and renewable energy, where upfront investments are substantial, and returns are not immediate.

Entrepreneurs, who are often the lifeblood of economic expansion and innovation, might find the new tax landscape particularly daunting. The increased cost of capital will deter them from launching new enterprises or expanding existing ones. Canada’s reputation as a nurturing ground for startups might see a downturn, impacting job creation and technological advancement.
Additionally, this shift could stifle the dynamic entrepreneurial spirit that is a hallmark of Canada’s business environment. A vibrant entrepreneurial ecosystem relies on a favorable investment climate, and if capital becomes more expensive, we might see a decline in the number of startups and innovative projects that get off the ground. This could lead to a broader economic impact, as fewer new businesses and innovations contribute less to overall economic diversity and resilience. Ultimately, while the goal of the tax increase is to promote fairness, the long-term consequences might include a less competitive and dynamic economic landscape in Canada.

What is the government’s objective?
The proposal to increase the capital gains tax rate to 67% for all corporations has stirred concerns about its potential impact on investment within the country. This change is set against the backdrop of higher interest rates that have already escalated the cost of borrowing, leading to a slowdown in investment across various sectors of the economy, and a housing shortage plus high rents, in part caused by high building and investment costs for capital.

Recognizing the challenges posed by elevated interest rates, the government has discussed measures aimed at reducing borrowing costs and increasing capital cost allowance rates to encourage more robust investment activities. Lower interest rates could potentially stimulate economic growth by making financing more accessible for businesses and consumers alike, thereby fostering an environment conducive to increased capital expenditure and expansion.

However, the proposed increase in capital gains taxation would counteract these efforts by raising the cost of capital through taxation. Higher taxes on capital gains will lead to a reduction in the net returns on investments, particularly affecting sectors that are heavily reliant on capital gains for growth and expansion, such as real estate and technology startups. This will desincentivize investors from engaging in long-term investments and riskier ventures that are essential for driving innovation and economic expansion.

The dual impact of high-interest rates and increased capital gains taxes creates a complex scenario for Canada’s investment climate. On one hand, reducing the cost of borrowing could help offset some negative effects of higher capital gains taxes. However, if the increased tax burden significantly outweighs the benefits of lower borrowing costs, it could still result in a net decrease in investment. Entrepreneurs and businesses may hesitate to invest in growth opportunities, potentially stifling Canada’s dynamic entrepreneurial spirit and impacting overall economic health. This juxtaposition of fiscal policies highlights the delicate balance the government must navigate to foster a healthy, vibrant economy while striving for tax fairness.

Economic Growth Considerations
While the Canadian government’s intentions to reform the capital gains tax system aim to promote equity, these changes risk significantly undermining economic growth. The decision to increase the inclusion rate for capital gains from 50% to 67% for significant earnings and corporate gains introduces a higher cost of capital, which could have deeply detrimental effects on Canada’s economic vitality. This increase will diminish the net returns on investments, potentially discouraging both domestic and international investors from allocating their resources to Canadian ventures.

The prospect of reduced investment attractiveness is particularly concerning as it positions Canada unfavorably compared to other nations with more lenient capital gains taxation. This could lead to a stark decrease in the flow of capital into critical industries like technology, housing, and manufacturing, which rely heavily on robust investment for innovation and expansion. The timing is especially inopportune, as these sectors are pivotal for driving forward national economic growth and technological leadership.

Furthermore, the increased cost of capital is likely to stifle not only the inflow of new investments but also the revaluation of ongoing investments and expansion plans by existing businesses. Companies may scale back or delay projects, leading to a widespread slowdown across various economic sectors. This slowdown could ripple through the economy, reducing job creation and technological advancement, directly contradicting the government’s broader economic goals.

Overall, the proposed tax reform, while aimed at achieving a fairer tax landscape, threatens to place Canada at a significant competitive disadvantage globally. It could deter investment and slow economic momentum at a time when proactive measures to enhance economic competitiveness are needed more than ever. This policy could be seen as a step backward, risking long-term economic stagnation in pursuit of short-term fiscal equity.
International Investment Disparity
A critical aspect to consider with the impending changes to Canada’s capital gains tax is the competitive disadvantage it imposes on Canadian investors relative to their international peers. The increase in the capital gains inclusion rate to 67% could position Canada as a less attractive investment destination, especially when compared to countries that offer lower tax rates or have favorable tax treaties with Canada. This shift might lead foreign investors to reconsider the viability of injecting their capital into the Canadian market.

Moreover, the international investment landscape is complicated by the fact that foreign corporations often pay capital gains taxes according to the rates in their home countries. This can create a significant tax advantage for non-resident corporations investing in Canadian assets over Canadian investors themselves. For instance, a U.S.-based company might be subject to a more favorable U.S. tax rate on capital gains than a Canadian investor would be under the new Canadian tax regime. This disparity could incentivize foreign corporations to invest in Canadian capital at a higher rate than Canadian nationals, leading to a situation where domestic capital flows outward in search of more tax-efficient investment opportunities.

The potential for capital flight is concerning, as it could lead to a drain of not just financial resources but also intellectual and entrepreneurial capital that might otherwise contribute to domestic economic growth and innovation. Canadian businesses and investors, facing a higher tax burden, may find it increasingly viable to invest in markets that promise higher after-tax returns, further exacerbating the economic challenges within Canada.

This international investment disparity, therefore, poses a significant risk: it could distort investment patterns, disadvantage Canadian capital, and ultimately slow the pace of economic development and innovation within the country. Such outcomes would counteract any intended fairness the tax reform aims to introduce, highlighting the need for careful consideration of global tax competitiveness in policy design.

Conclusion
As a Chartered Professional Accountant and Tax Expert, it is essential to critically assess how these changes in the capital gains tax regime will affect not only tax fairness but also investment attractiveness and economic health in Canada. While the intent behind the adjustments is commendable—aiming to ensure a more equitable tax landscape—the potential repercussions on investment and economic vibrancy need careful consideration. Fairness should include discussions on the risks taken by entrepreneurs and recognition of the key role businesses play in the Canadian economy.

To all family-owned enterprises and investors in Canada, it’s crucial to revisit financial and investment plans to adapt effectively to these changes. As your dedicated tax professional, I am here to guide you through these new challenges, ensuring that your financial goals align with the evolving tax environment in Canada and take advantage of opportunities abroad. Tell us your ambitions, and let us guide you there, through informed decisions and strategic planning in response to Canada’s new tax environment.

This information is for discussion purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. There is no guarantee or warrant of information on this site and it should be noted that rules and laws change regularly. You should consult a professional before considering implementing or taking any action based on information on this site. Call our team for a consultation before taking any action. ©2024 Shajani CPA.

Shajani CPA is a CPA Calgary, Edmonton and Red Deer firm and provides Accountant, Bookkeeping, Tax Advice and Tax Planning service.