Big Tax Changes Coming: How to Protect Your Investments and Secure Your Financial Future

As Canada gears up for significant tax changes, understanding how these adjustments will impact your financial future is crucial. Starting June 25, 2024, the capital gains inclusion rate is set to increase, leading to higher taxes on your investments. Whether you’re a small business owner planning your retirement or an individual with substantial investments, proactive tax planning has never been more important. This blog will guide you through the changes, illustrate their effects, and provide strategic solutions to help you navigate this new landscape with confidence. Read on to learn how to protect your wealth and ensure financial stability amidst these changes.

What Are Capital Gains?

Definition of Capital Gains

Capital gains are the profits realized from the sale of an asset or investment. These gains occur when the selling price of the asset exceeds its purchase price, or adjusted cost base (ACB). Capital gains can be realized from various types of capital properties, such as stocks, real estate, and business interests. In Canada, a portion of these gains is included in the taxpayer’s income and subjected to taxation, which is referred to as the capital gains inclusion rate.

The ACB includes the original purchase price plus any additional costs incurred to acquire the asset, such as commissions or legal fees. When you sell the asset, the capital gain is calculated by subtracting the ACB from the proceeds of disposition (the selling price). For instance, if you bought a piece of land for $200,000 and sold it for $300,000, your capital gain would be $100,000.

Types of Capital Property

Capital property encompasses a wide range of assets, each subject to capital gains tax when sold at a profit. The primary types of capital property include:

1. Stocks and Securities: Investments in publicly traded companies’ shares or bonds fall into this category. These are among the most common forms of capital property for individual investors.
2. Real Estate: This includes residential properties, commercial buildings, and land. Real estate investments often yield significant capital gains, especially in markets with rising property values.
3. Business Interests: Ownership stakes in private businesses or partnerships are also considered capital property. Selling a business or shares in a private company can generate substantial capital gains.
4. Collectibles and Personal Use Property: Items such as artwork, rare coins, and other collectibles can appreciate in value over time. Personal use property, like a second home or vacation property, can also result in capital gains when sold.
5. Mutual Funds and ETFs: Investments in mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are treated as capital property. Gains realized from selling these investments are subject to capital gains tax.

Importance of Capital Gains in Investment and Business

Capital gains play a crucial role in investment and business strategies for several reasons:

1. Wealth Accumulation: Capital gains represent a primary avenue for wealth accumulation. Investors purchase assets with the expectation that their value will increase over time, allowing them to sell at a profit. This growth contributes significantly to the overall net worth of individuals and businesses.
2. Tax Efficiency: In many tax systems, including Canada’s, capital gains are taxed at a lower rate than ordinary income. This preferential treatment encourages long-term investment and strategic asset allocation. By focusing on investments that appreciate in value, individuals and businesses can optimize their tax liabilities.
3. Economic Growth: Capital gains are indicative of economic growth and prosperity. Rising asset values reflect a healthy economy where businesses are expanding, property values are increasing, and investor confidence is high. This growth fuels further investment and spending, driving the broader economy forward.
4. Investment Incentives: The potential for capital gains incentivizes investment in various sectors, including technology, real estate, and small businesses. Investors are more likely to fund startups and innovative projects when they anticipate significant returns on their investments. This influx of capital supports entrepreneurship, job creation, and technological advancement.
5. Retirement Planning: For many individuals, capital gains form a key component of retirement planning. Investments in real estate, stocks, and mutual funds are expected to appreciate over time, providing a financial cushion for retirement. Managing capital gains effectively through tax planning and strategic asset sales ensures a stable income during retirement years.

In summary, capital gains are a fundamental aspect of financial growth and stability. They represent the profit from strategic investments and play a vital role in wealth accumulation, tax planning, and economic development. By understanding the types of capital property and the implications of capital gains, investors can make informed decisions that support their financial goals and contribute to broader economic prosperity.

Calculating Capital Gains: Tax Impact on Personal and Business Investments

Understanding the true impact of taxes on investments requires analyzing the initial taxation of earned income and the subsequent capital gains tax. Here, we illustrate how $100,000 of earned income is taxed under three scenarios: personal investment, small business investment, and general corporate investment. We will also consider the distribution of the remaining funds to the shareholder, utilizing the Capital Dividend Account (CDA) where applicable.

Scenario 1: Personal Investment

Step 1: Tax on Earned Income

• Earned Income: $100,000
• Personal Tax Rate: 48%
• Tax Paid: $100,000 × 48% = $48,000
• After-Tax Income Available for Investment: $100,000 – $48,000 = $52,000

Step 2: Investment and Capital Gain

• Initial Investment: $52,000
• Value Doubles: $52,000 × 2 = $104,000
• Capital Gain: $104,000 – $52,000 = $52,000
• Taxable Capital Gain (current 50% inclusion rate for the first $250,000): $52,000 × 50% = $26,000
• Tax on Capital Gain: $26,000 × 48% = $12,480

Proposed New Taxable Capital Gain (66.67% inclusion rate above $250,000): If applicable, adjust for gains over $250,000 (in this case, it doesn’t apply).

Total Tax Paid:

• Initial Tax: $48,000
• Tax on Capital Gain: $12,480
• Total Tax Paid: $48,000 + $12,480 = $60,480

Net After-Tax Amount: $104,000 – $12,480 = $91,520

Scenario 2: Small Business Investment

Step 1: Tax on Earned Income

• Earned Income: $100,000
• Small Business Tax Rate: 11%
• Tax Paid: $100,000 × 11% = $11,000
• After-Tax Income Available for Investment: $100,000 – $11,000 = $89,000

Step 2: Investment and Capital Gain

• Initial Investment: $89,000
• Value Doubles: $89,000 × 2 = $178,000
• Capital Gain: $178,000 – $89,000 = $89,000
• Taxable Capital Gain (new 66.67% inclusion rate): $89,000 × 66.67% = $59,346.30
• Tax on Capital Gain (assuming passive income at general corporate rate 23%): $59,346.30 × 23% = $13,648.70
• CDA Addition (Non-Taxable Portion): $29,653.70 (1/3 of $89,000)

Step 3: Distribution to Shareholder

• Distribution via CDA: $29,653.70 (tax-free)
• Remaining Distribution: $148,346.30
• Tax on Remaining Distribution (dividend tax rate 31.71%): $148,346.30 × 31.71% = $47,030.47

Total Tax Paid:

• Initial Tax: $11,000
• Tax on Capital Gain: $13,648.70
• Tax on Dividend: $47,030.47
• Total Tax Paid: $11,000 + $13,648.70 + $47,030.47 = $71,679.17

Net After-Tax Amount: $178,000 – $71,679.17 = $106,320.83

Scenario 3: General Corporate Investment

Step 1: Tax on Earned Income

• Earned Income: $100,000
• General Corporate Tax Rate: 23%
• Tax Paid: $100,000 × 23% = $23,000
• After-Tax Income Available for Investment: $100,000 – $23,000 = $77,000

Step 2: Investment and Capital Gain

• Initial Investment: $77,000
• Value Doubles: $77,000 × 2 = $154,000
• Capital Gain: $154,000 – $77,000 = $77,000
• Taxable Capital Gain (new 66.67% inclusion rate): $77,000 × 66.67% = $51,335.90
• Tax on Capital Gain: $51,335.90 × 23% = $11,807.26
• CDA Addition (Non-Taxable Portion): $25,664.10 (1/3 of $77,000)

Step 3: Distribution to Shareholder

• Distribution via CDA: $25,664.10 (tax-free)
• Remaining Distribution: $128,335.90
• Tax on Remaining Distribution (dividend tax rate 31.71%): $128,335.90 × 31.71% = $40,690.99

Total Tax Paid:

• Initial Tax: $23,000
• Tax on Capital Gain: $11,807.26
• Tax on Dividend: $40,690.99
• Total Tax Paid: $23,000 + $11,807.26 + $40,690.99 = $75,498.25

Net After-Tax Amount: $154,000 – $75,498.25 = $78,501.75

Summary of Total Taxes Paid and Net After-Tax Amounts

1. Personal Investment:
   • Total Tax Paid: $60,480
   • Net After-Tax Amount: $91,520
2. Small Business Investment:
   • Total Tax Paid: $71,679.17
   • Net After-Tax Amount: $106,320.83
3. General Corporate Investment:
   • Total Tax Paid: $75,498.25
   • Net After-Tax Amount: $78,501.75

Conclusion

The comparison reveals that personal investments incur a moderate total tax, while small business investments and general corporate investments face higher overall tax burdens. However, small business investments result in a higher net after-tax amount than general corporate investments due to the lower initial tax rate and the benefit of the CDA.

Understanding these scenarios helps investors optimize their tax strategies based on their specific circumstances. Shajani CPA can provide expert guidance to navigate these complexities and enhance your financial outcomes.

Changes in Capital Gains Inclusion Rate

Current Inclusion Rate: 50%

Under the current Canadian tax system, capital gains are included in taxable income at a rate of 50%. This means that only half of the capital gain realized from the sale of a capital property is subject to income tax. For instance, if an individual or corporation realizes a capital gain of $10,000, only $5,000 is included in their taxable income. This preferential treatment of capital gains, compared to ordinary income, encourages investment by reducing the tax burden on profits from the sale of capital assets.

Proposed Changes (Effective June 25, 2024)

The Canadian government has proposed significant changes to the capital gains inclusion rate, set to take effect on June 25, 2024. These changes are part of the government’s efforts to increase tax revenues and address perceived inequities in the tax system. The key proposed changes are:

1. Increase to 66.67% for Corporations and Trusts:
   • For corporations and most types of trusts, the inclusion rate for capital gains will increase from 50% to 66.67%. This means that two-thirds of the capital gain will now be included in taxable income, up from the current half. For example, if a corporation realizes a capital gain of $10,000, $6,667 will be included in its taxable income, compared to $5,000 under the current system.
2. Increase for Individuals on Capital Gains Exceeding $250,000:
   • For individuals, the inclusion rate will remain at 50% for the first $250,000 of capital gains realized in a year. However, any capital gains exceeding this threshold will be subject to the new 66.67% inclusion rate. This tiered approach aims to maintain some level of tax relief for smaller gains while increasing the tax burden on larger gains.

Implications for Different Taxpayer Categories

The proposed changes will have varied implications for different taxpayer categories, including individuals, corporations, and trusts.

1. Individuals:
   • Impact on High Earners:
     • Individuals who realize significant capital gains exceeding $250,000 in a year will see a substantial increase in their tax liabilities. For instance, if an individual realizes $300,000 in capital gains, the first $250,000 will be included at 50% ($125,000 taxable), and the remaining $50,000 will be included at 66.67% ($33,335 taxable). This results in a higher overall tax burden, particularly for those with substantial investment portfolios or real estate holdings.
   • Strategic Timing of Sales:
     • The changes may encourage individuals to strategically time their asset sales to stay below the $250,000 threshold each year, thus minimizing the impact of the higher inclusion rate. Investors may also consider spreading out sales over multiple years to take advantage of the lower rate for the first $250,000.
2. Corporations:
   • Increased Tax Burden:
     • Corporations will face a higher tax burden on capital gains due to the increased inclusion rate. This change will impact investment decisions and financial planning strategies, particularly for businesses that rely on the sale of capital assets for revenue.
   • Review of Investment Strategies:
     • Corporations may need to review and adjust their investment strategies, considering the higher tax rate on realized gains. This could involve holding assets longer to defer tax liabilities or exploring alternative investment opportunities with lower tax implications.
3. Trusts:
   • Higher Taxes for Trusts:
     • Trusts, like corporations, will be subject to the higher 66.67% inclusion rate. This change will affect the tax planning strategies of trusts, including estate planning and the management of investment portfolios.
   • Impact on Beneficiaries:
     • The increased tax burden on trusts may also impact the distributions to beneficiaries, as the trust will have less after-tax income to distribute. Beneficiaries may see lower distributions or need to plan for higher tax liabilities on their end.

Overall Implications:

The proposed changes to the capital gains inclusion rate represent a significant shift in Canada’s tax landscape. While the changes aim to increase tax revenues and address fairness concerns, they also pose challenges for taxpayers who must adapt their financial and tax planning strategies. Individuals, corporations, and trusts will need to reassess their investment strategies, consider the timing of asset sales, and explore ways to mitigate the impact of higher taxes on capital gains. Engaging with tax professionals, such as Shajani CPA, can help navigate these changes and optimize financial outcomes under the new tax regime.

Impact on Small Business Enterprises

The proposed increase in the capital gains inclusion rate presents significant challenges for small business owners. This change, effective June 25, 2024, increases the capital gains inclusion rate from 50% to 66.67% for corporations and trusts, and for individuals on capital gains exceeding $250,000. Small business owners, particularly those planning to sell their businesses or relying on investments within their corporations for retirement, will face a higher tax burden, impacting their financial planning and long-term economic stability.

Challenges Faced by Small Business Owners

Small business owners often have a substantial portion of their wealth tied up in their businesses. Selling their business is a critical part of their retirement strategy. The increased inclusion rate will result in higher taxes on the sale of their business, reducing the net proceeds available for retirement. Additionally, small business owners who have accumulated investments within their corporations for retirement purposes will face higher taxes when realizing these gains, diminishing their retirement savings.

Example Scenario: Small Business Owner Selling Their Business

To illustrate the impact, consider a small business owner in Alberta selling their business.

• Sale Price: $1,000,000
• Adjusted Cost Base (ACB): $400,000
• Capital Gain: $1,000,000 – $400,000 = $600,000

Current Tax Scenario (50% Inclusion Rate):

• Taxable Capital Gain: $600,000 × 50% = $300,000
• Tax Payable (assume 48% marginal tax rate): $300,000 × 48% = $144,000
• Net After-Tax Proceeds: $1,000,000 – $144,000 = $856,000

Proposed Tax Scenario (66.67% Inclusion Rate):

• Taxable Capital Gain: $600,000 × 66.67% = $400,020
• Tax Payable: $400,020 × 48% = $192,009.60
• Net After-Tax Proceeds: $1,000,000 – $192,009.60 = $807,990.40

Impact:

• Increase in Tax Payable: $192,009.60 – $144,000 = $48,009.60
• Decrease in Net After-Tax Proceeds: $856,000 – $807,990.40 = $48,009.60

The Fairness Debate: Small Business vs. Large Corporations

The increase in the capital gains inclusion rate raises questions about fairness. While large corporations have more resources to manage and mitigate tax impacts, small business owners may not have the same level of financial flexibility. The tax burden on small businesses may be disproportionate, as they often rely on the sale of their business or corporate investments as a primary source of retirement income.

Large corporations typically have diversified portfolios and access to sophisticated tax planning strategies, allowing them to absorb tax increases more effectively. In contrast, small business owners, especially those nearing retirement, may find their financial plans significantly disrupted by the sudden increase in taxes.

Long-Term Economic Impact on Family-Owned Enterprises

Family-owned enterprises play a crucial role in the economy, contributing to job creation and community stability. The increased tax burden may deter entrepreneurship and reduce the attractiveness of investing in small businesses. Over time, this could lead to fewer family-owned enterprises and a potential decline in local economic activity.

For those approaching retirement, the proposed changes could have a devastating impact. Many small business owners have planned their retirement around the proceeds from the sale of their business or investments within their corporation. The higher inclusion rate reduces the value of these investments, undermining decades of financial planning.

Example Impact on Retirement Savings:

Assume a small business owner has $1,000,000 in investments within their corporation, with an original investment cost of $500,000. The capital gain is $500,000.

• Current Tax Scenario:
  • Taxable Capital Gain (50% inclusion rate): $500,000 × 50% = $250,000
  • Tax Payable (48% rate): $250,000 × 48% = $120,000
  • Net After-Tax Amount: $1,000,000 – $120,000 = $880,000
• Proposed Tax Scenario:
  • Taxable Capital Gain (66.67% inclusion rate): $500,000 × 66.67% = $333,350
  • Tax Payable: $333,350 × 48% = $160,008
  • Net After-Tax Amount: $1,000,000 – $160,008 = $839,992

Percentage Decline in Savings:

• Current Net Amount: $880,000
• Proposed Net Amount: $839,992
• Decline: $880,000 – $839,992 = $40,008
• Percentage Decline: ($40,008 / $880,000) × 100 = 4.55%

For small business owners nearing retirement, a 4.55% decline in savings due to increased taxes represents a significant financial setback. This reduction can impact their standard of living and the sustainability of their retirement income.

Conclusion

The proposed increase in the capital gains inclusion rate presents substantial challenges for small business owners. The higher tax burden reduces the net proceeds from the sale of their businesses and diminishes the value of corporate investments intended for retirement. The fairness debate highlights the disproportionate impact on small businesses compared to large corporations. Long-term economic implications include potential declines in family-owned enterprises and reduced local economic activity. Engaging with tax professionals, such as Shajani CPA, can help small business owners navigate these changes and optimize their financial outcomes amidst the evolving tax landscape.

Strategic Tax Planning Under the New Rules

The proposed changes to the capital gains inclusion rate, effective June 25, 2024, necessitate careful strategic tax planning for individuals and businesses. By understanding and utilizing available tax-saving opportunities, taxpayers can mitigate the impact of the higher inclusion rate.

Timing of Asset Sales and Capital Gains

Timing the sale of assets is a critical strategy under the new rules. For individuals and businesses, realizing capital gains before the new inclusion rate takes effect can significantly reduce the tax burden. This involves accelerating the sale of assets planned for later years to benefit from the current 50% inclusion rate.

For example, if an individual plans to sell a property or a stock portfolio that has appreciated significantly, doing so before June 25, 2024, ensures that only half of the capital gain is taxable. This can result in substantial tax savings, especially for high-value transactions.

Utilizing the $250,000 Threshold for Individuals

The new rules maintain the 50% inclusion rate for the first $250,000 of capital gains realized by individuals annually. This threshold provides an opportunity for individuals to manage their gains strategically.

To take advantage of this threshold, individuals can spread out the sale of assets over multiple years, ensuring that each year’s gains remain below $250,000. This approach minimizes the portion of gains subject to the higher 66.67% inclusion rate, reducing overall tax liability.

For instance, instead of selling a large investment in one year and incurring a higher tax, an individual could sell portions of the investment each year, staying within the $250,000 threshold. This staggered approach can significantly lower the effective tax rate on capital gains.

Exploring Other Tax-Saving Opportunities

Other tax-saving strategies can also help mitigate the impact of the increased inclusion rate. These include:

• Tax-Loss Harvesting: Selling investments at a loss to offset gains can reduce taxable income. By strategically timing the realization of losses, taxpayers can lower the net capital gain subject to the higher inclusion rate.
• Tax-Deferred Accounts: Utilizing tax-deferred accounts, such as RRSPs and TFSAs, can shelter investments from immediate taxation. Gains within these accounts are not taxed until withdrawn (RRSPs) or are completely tax-free (TFSAs).
• Income Splitting: Transferring income or gains to family members in lower tax brackets can reduce the overall tax burden. This strategy is particularly useful for family-owned businesses and trusts.

The Role of Professional Advice in Navigating These Changes

Given the complexity of the new tax rules and their significant impact on financial planning, professional advice is more critical than ever. Tax professionals, such as those at Shajani CPA, can provide tailored strategies to help individuals and businesses navigate these changes effectively.

Professional advisors can assist with:

• Evaluating and Timing Asset Sales: Analyzing the best times to sell assets to maximize tax savings.
• Utilizing Tax Shelters and Deductions: Identifying and applying available tax shelters and deductions to reduce taxable income.
• Strategic Estate Planning: Ensuring that estate plans are optimized for the new tax environment, particularly for family-owned enterprises.
• Ongoing Tax Planning: Providing continuous advice and adjustments as tax laws and financial circumstances change.

Conclusion

The proposed changes to the capital gains inclusion rate present significant challenges and opportunities for taxpayers. By strategically timing asset sales, utilizing the $250,000 threshold, exploring other tax-saving opportunities, and seeking professional advice, individuals and businesses can effectively manage the impact of these changes.

For small business owners and individuals with substantial investments, proactive tax planning is essential to preserve wealth and ensure financial stability. Engaging with tax professionals, like those at Shajani CPA, can provide the expertise and guidance needed to navigate the complexities of the new tax rules and optimize financial outcomes.

Strategic tax planning not only helps in mitigating the immediate impact of higher taxes but also ensures long-term financial health and resilience in an evolving tax landscape. Tell us your ambitions, and we will guide you there.

Conclusion

Recap of the Changes and Their Significance

The proposed changes to the capital gains inclusion rate, set to take effect on June 25, 2024, mark a significant shift in Canada’s tax landscape. The inclusion rate will increase from 50% to 66.67% for corporations and trusts, and for individuals on capital gains exceeding $250,000 annually. These changes will result in a higher tax burden on realized capital gains, impacting individuals, small business owners, and large corporations alike. The new rules aim to increase tax revenues and address perceived inequities, but they also pose substantial challenges, particularly for those nearing retirement or relying on investments for financial security.

The Need for Proactive Tax Planning

Given the increased tax burden, proactive tax planning is essential to mitigate the impact of these changes. Strategies such as timing asset sales to benefit from the current inclusion rate, utilizing the $250,000 threshold for individuals, and exploring other tax-saving opportunities like tax-loss harvesting and income splitting can significantly reduce taxable income. For small business owners and individuals with substantial investments, the importance of reevaluating and adjusting financial plans cannot be overstated. Proactive tax planning helps preserve wealth, ensure financial stability, and optimize outcomes in light of the new tax environment.

How Shajani CPA Can Help You Navigate These Changes

Navigating these complex tax changes requires expertise and strategic planning. At Shajani CPA, we understand the intricacies of the Canadian tax system and the unique challenges posed by the new capital gains inclusion rate. Our team of experienced professionals is committed to helping you optimize your financial strategies and minimize your tax liabilities.

We offer personalized advice tailored to your specific circumstances, whether you are an individual investor, a small business owner, or part of a larger corporation. Our services include:

• Strategic Tax Planning: We analyze your financial situation and provide detailed strategies to manage asset sales, utilize tax shelters, and optimize deductions.
• Investment and Estate Planning: Our advisors help you structure investments and estate plans to maximize tax efficiency and ensure long-term financial health.
• Continuous Support: Tax laws and financial conditions change. We provide ongoing advice and adjustments to keep your tax strategy aligned with your goals.

At Shajani CPA, we are dedicated to guiding you through these tax changes with confidence and expertise. Our goal is to help you achieve your financial ambitions while ensuring compliance with the evolving tax regulations.

By partnering with Shajani CPA, you gain access to a team of professionals who are committed to your financial success. We work closely with you to understand your needs and develop customized solutions that address your specific challenges. Whether you need assistance with immediate tax planning or long-term financial strategy, we are here to support you every step of the way.

Tell us your ambitions, and we will guide you there. Let Shajani CPA be your trusted advisor in navigating these significant tax changes and optimizing your financial future. Reach out to us today to learn how we can help you achieve your financial goals amidst the evolving tax landscape.

 

This information is for discussion purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. There is no guarantee or warrant of information on this site and it should be noted that rules and laws change regularly. You should consult a professional before considering implementing or taking any action based on information on this site. Call our team for a consultation before taking any action. ©2024 Shajani CPA.

Shajani CPA is a CPA Calgary, Edmonton and Red Deer firm and provides Accountant, Bookkeeping, Tax Advice and Tax Planning service.

Trusts – Estate Planning – Tax Advisory – Tax Law – T2200 – T5108 – Audit Shield – Corporate Tax – Personal Tax – CRA – CPA Alberta – Russell Bedford – Income Tax – Family Owned Business – Alberta Business – Expenses – Audits – Reviews – Compilations – Mergers – Acquisitions – Cash Flow Management – QuickBooks – Ai Accounting – Automation – Startups – Litigation Support – International Tax – US Tax – Business Succession Planning – Business Purchase – Sale of Business